| Perfect Cast (20 points) | Completed a perfect cast |
| First Season Complete (100 points) | Complete all 10 lakes and 10 tournaments |
| Lake Fork Unlocked (20 points) | Complete Lake Ouachita tournament |
| Lake Ouachita Unlocked (20 points) | Complete Lake Amistad tournament |
| Lake Wylie Unlocked (20 points) | Complete Lake Fork tournament |
| Lake Guntersville Unlocked (20 points) | Complete Lake Wylie tournament |
| Lake Champlain Unlocked (20 points) | Complete Lake Guntersville tournament |
| Lake Oneida Unlocked (20 points) | Complete Lake Champlain tournament |
| Lake Pickwick Unlocked (20 points) | Complete Lake Oneida tournament |
| Lake Toho Unlocked (20 points) | Complete Lake Pickwick tournament |
| What a Haul (50 points) | Catch 1000 pounds of fish |
| Casting Champion (50 points) | Achieve a perfect score in a Casting Challenge mini game |
| Legendary Angler (100 points) | Catch all 10 legendary fish |
| Brilliant Cast (50 points) | Cast a line over 135 feet |
| Perfectionist (50 points) | Complete 10 perfect casts |
| Renowned (50 points) | Earned 500 reputation points in career mode |
| Money Bags (50 points) | Earn $1000 |
| Filthy Rich (50 points) | Earn $2000 |
| Experienced Angler (100 points) | Catch a total of 200 fish |
| BPS Invitational Challenge (100 points) | Complete all 5 Bass Pro Shops invitational tournaments |
| Intrepid Explorer (50 points) | Locate all 50 exploration spots to complete this challenge |
| Table Rock Lake Unlocked (20 points) | Complete Lake Toho tournament |